How sanctions laws affect publishing: OFAC provides new guidance
Elsevier has encouraged “freedom of expression” for scientific authors in sanctioned countries such as Iran, Cuba, Sudan, Burma and Syria
By Mark Seeley, Esq Posted on 8 December 2015
Some of you will be aware that Elsevier has been attempting to clarify the “publishing exception” issued by the US government agency OFAC (Office of Foreign Assets Control) in 2007 related to trade sanctions laws. (See our prior Elsevier Connect post.)
We have now received OFAC’s response to our request, and while we believe the US government could have been clearer and more forthright in supporting international publishing activities, we think the communication makes clear that the vast majority of publishing activities are consistent with OFAC regulations.
Elsevier had asked OFAC to explain how we are supposed to understand the general ability to publish the works of authors in sanction countries with the exception that this did not necessarily apply to “government employee” authors. We pointed out that in most countries, universities and research institutions are almost always government institutions.
It is clear in the October 2015 response from OFAC (which we present below) that publishing activities conducted by sanction country authors in their personal professional capacity, even if they are working at a government institution, is not problematic. Even if the author was preparing the paper or contribution on behalf of their government institution, if that institution was primarily involved in education or research, then this is also permitted. Issues would only arise where the author was preparing a work on behalf of their government agency and that agency was not primarily an educational or research institution.
It is hard to imagine that this latter scenario would be applicable for the vast majority of research papers or medically or research-oriented book contributions, but even in such an unlikely scenario, there are publishing solutions that would enable us to publish (for example, we could publish but provide less in the way of editing). The only country/region where the US regulations are currently unclear is the Crimean region, and both the US and EU governmental authorities still reserve the right to take actions against individuals or organizations that they specifically identify as terrorist-related.
At Elsevier, we are modifying our publishing agreements to take into account this guidance, but we are pleased that we are able to bring this matter to a close in a way that is consistent with our fundamental freedom of expression view that publishing is a global international method of communication, and that censorship plays no part in such an environment.
To be clear, we summarize our views of the OFAC guidance (having to do with Iran, Cuba, Sudan, Burma and Syria):
- There are no publishing limitations with respect to authors or co-authors in these sanctioned countries who are engaged in preparing an article, chapter or book in their “personal capacity” (in other words, “not as an official representative or otherwise on behalf of a sanctioned government”).
- Even if the author or co-author is acting on behalf of the government or government agency in his or her publishing activities (which would be highly unusual in our field), there is no problem with the editing and publication of the work if the co-author is employed at an academic or research institution where research or education is the primary function of the entity.
- Even if an author or co-author is preparing a publication on behalf of a government agency, and even if that agency is not primarily involved in research or education, the content prepared by the author or co-author can be published provided that no substantive editing (i.e., substantive or artistic alteration or enhancement of the work) is provided by the editor, reviewers or publisher (for US nationals) – essentially, pre-existing “camera ready” articles (or pre-prints) for which Elsevier provides only minimal style and copy editing.
If you have any questions about this guidance or its application, please let us know!
Read OFAC’s letter to Elsevier
Elsevier Connect Contributor
Mark Seeley is Elsevier's SVP and General Counsel and Chair of the Copyright and Legal Affairs Committee of the International Association of Scientific, Technical & Medical Publishers (STM). He is based in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
By Mark Seeley, Esq | Posted on 23 Jan 2015
Letter – and support for industry communications – focus on “freedom of expression” concerns in scientific publishingBy Mark Seeley | Posted on 14 Oct 2013
Letter to the US Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) asks that government employee researchers be allowed to publishBy Mark Seeley | Posted on 26 Sep 2013
Why concepts like ‘proof’ and ‘ethics’ can take on new meaning in the realm of scholarly publishing