Content policy and selection criteria
All-encompassing engineering literature database
Compendex comprises the most comprehensive engineering literature research in the world. It is continually updated, providing the engineering community with a timely and relevant resource for engineering research and discovery.
Periodically, new engineering publications are identified and selected for inclusion in the Compendex engineering database, while other currently covered engineering publications may be discontinued. Selections for new publications and content are made, in part, with the advice of external, independent reviewers, based on their professional expertise and background.
Engineering publications that are selected contain articles predominantly on core engineering subjects. Publications whose content is peripheral, or related, to engineering are occasionally evaluated, taking into consideration both the quality of the publication's engineering content, and the contribution its content makes to overall coverage of its particular subject in Compendex.
Journal selection criteria
Initial eligibility of journals will be evaluated on adherence to the following minimum criteria:
Valid, Registered ISSN | Peer-review | English Abstracts | -Regular Publication -2-year publication history -Regular publishing output | -Publication Ethics Statement (COPE) -Publishing Ethics Resource Kit (PERK) -Digital Preservation Policy (PORTICO) -The CLOCKSS Archive |
|---|
Eligible titles are reviewed according to a combination of quantitative and qualitative selection criteria:
Journal Policy | Quality of Content | Journal Standing | Regularity | Online Availability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Convincing editorial concept/policy | Academic contribution to the field | Citedness of journal articles, including self-citation rate | No delay or interruption in publication schedules | Content available online |
Type of peer-review | Clarity of abstracts | For local Chinese journals, ISTIC & other national rankings are consulted | Volume/issue frequency and article output should be reliable and predictable | Digital policies and preservation practices |
Diversity and geographic distribution of editors | Quality and conformity with stated aims & scope | English-language journal home page | ||
Diversity and geographic distribution of authors | Readability of articles | Quality of home page | ||
Digital object Identifier |
Selection criteria for Conference proceedings
Initial eligibility of conference proceedings will be evaluated on adherence to the following minimum criteria:
Valid, Registered ISSN/ISBN | Peer-review | Full-text Papers with English Abstracts | Content Accessible Online | Publication Ethics Statement |
|---|
Eligible titles are reviewed according to a combination of quantitative and qualitative selection criteria:
Conference Policy | Conference Organization | Quality of Content | Conference Standing | Online Availability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Convincing and focused scope | Disclosure of partners/sponsors | Technical, scientific, and written quality of titles/abstracts | Reputation/standing of the technical and program committees | English-language conference home page |
Transparent peer-review policy | Transparent guidelines and instructions for authors | Academic contribution to the field | Conference included in authoritative list | Quality of home page |
Geographic diversity and distribution of technical and program committees | Transparent fee structure | Readability of articles | Digital object Identifier | |
Geographic diversity and distribution of authors | Quality and conformity with stated aims & scope | |||
Originality/authenticity of papers |
Engineering publications and content: A checklist for successful inclusion
Engineering publications and content should meet the following criteria:
Journals must have an International Standard Serial Number (ISSN) as registered with the ISSN International Centre(opens in new tab/window).
Engineering publications must have an English-language title and publish English-language abstracts for all engineering research articles. However, full-text articles can be in any language.
Informative, rather than indicative abstracts are preferred.
The clarity of abstracts is evaluated.
Publications are suggested to have at least two-year publication history and have demonstrated publish issues in a timely manner and regularly, with a minimum of one issue per year (the exceptions being conference proceedings or monographic series which may be published less frequently).
Publications must consist of peer-reviewed engineering content and have a publicly available description of the peer review process. Exceptions would be trade journals and some conference proceedings.
Publications must exhibit authority, often represented in the reputation of a commercial or society publisher.
Publications must have a convincing editorial policy, with conformity to the stated aims and scope of the publication.
Publications must comprise engineering content that is relevant for and readable by an international audience, e.g., they must have English language abstracts and publications, and have references in Roman script.
Overall quality must be high. Assessment of a publication's quality may include, but is not limited to, the following:
Academic contribution to the field wherein content and scientific merit (validity, importance, originality, and contribution to the coverage of the field in the overall contents of each engineering publication) are key factors considered in recommending a publication for indexing, whatever the intended purpose and audience. Articles represent original research of importance to the global scientific community.
International/geographic diversity of authors and editors.
Engineering publications must have a publicly available publication ethics and publication malpractice statement and adhere to publication ethics practices.
Publications must have a publicly available policy demonstrating adherence to digital preservation practice(s).
The appearance of the publication, i.e., print/paper/electronic/website, etc., must be high quality, clear, and accessible:
Either the full text or tables of contents must be available online, with a high quality English-language home page available.
Articles and abstracts must be clear and readable.
Engineering publications that consist primarily of content from reprinted articles, reports of association activities, abstracts of engineering literature, news items, or book reviews, will typically not be considered for selection.