COVID-19 Update: We are currently shipping orders daily. However, due to transit disruptions in some geographies, deliveries may be delayed. To provide all customers with timely access to content, we are offering 50% off Science and Technology Print & eBook bundle options. Terms & conditions.
The Acquisition of Strategic Knowledge - 1st Edition - ISBN: 9780123047540, 9780323162586

The Acquisition of Strategic Knowledge

1st Edition

Author: Thomas R. Gruber
eBook ISBN: 9780323162586
Imprint: Academic Press
Published Date: 28th November 1989
Page Count: 336
Sales tax will be calculated at check-out Price includes VAT/GST
Price includes VAT/GST

Institutional Subscription

Secure Checkout

Personal information is secured with SSL technology.

Free Shipping

Free global shipping
No minimum order.


The Acquisition of Strategic Knowledge deals with the automation of the acquisition of strategic knowledge and describes a knowledge acquisition program called ASK, which elicits strategic knowledge from domain experts and puts it in operational form. This book explores the dynamics of intelligent systems and how the components of knowledge systems (including a human expert) interact to produce intelligence. Emphasis is placed on how to represent knowledge that experts require to make decisions about actions. The move toward abstract tasks and how tasks are solved are discussed, along with their implications for knowledge acquisition, particularly the acquisition of expert strategies. This book is comprised of eight chapters and begins with an overview of the knowledge acquisition problem for strategic knowledge, as well as the relevance of strategic knowledge to artificial intelligence. The next chapter describes a dialog session between the ASK knowledge acquisition assistant and the user (""the expert""). The discussion then turns to software architecture with which to represent strategic knowledge; design and implementation of an assistant for acquiring strategic knowledge; and approaches to knowledge acquisition. Two applications of the ASK system are considered: to evaluate the usability of the elicitation technique with real users and to test the adequacy of the strategy rule representation upon which the approach is dependent. The scope of ASK, its sources of power, and its underlying assumptions are also outlined. This monograph will be a valuable resource for knowledge systems designers and those interested in artificial intelligence and expert systems.

Table of Contents




1 Introduction and Overview

1.1 The Knowledge Acquisition Problem

1.1.1 Why is Knowledge Acquisition Difficult

1.1.2 Automating Knowledge Acquisition

1.2 Strategic Knowledge

1.2.1 What is Strategic Knowledge

1.2.2 Strategic and Substantive Knowledge

1.2.3 Strategic Knowledge and Search Control

1.2.4 Strategic Knowledge and Planning

1.2.5 Strategic Expertise

1.3 The Problem of Acquiring Strategic Knowledge

1.3.1 The Current Approach

1.3.2 Why Acquire Strategic Knowledge

1.4 An Approach to the Acquisition of Strategic Knowledge

1.5 Overview of the Ask Knowledge Acquisition Assistant

1.6 An Example Dialog with Ask

1.7 An Analysis of the Sources of Power in Ask

1.8 Scope of Applicability of Ask

1.9 Assumptions and Limitations

1.10 Major Conclusions

2. A Knowledge Acquisition Dialog

2.1 The Domain: A Workup for Chest Pain

2.2 What the System Already Knows

2.3 Running the Application System

2.4 The Knowledge Acquisition Dialog

2.4.1 Eliciting the Expert's Critique

2.4.2 Eliciting Justifications

2.4.3 Generating and Verifying a Strategy Rule

2.4.4 Acquiring a New Term

2.4.5 Generalizing the New Rule

2.4.6 Acquiring Trade-offs Among Features

2.5 Summary of the Dialog Session

3. Representing Strategic Knowledge

3.1 Design Criteria for a Representation of Strategic Knowledge

3.1.1 General Principles of the Design of Representations for Knowledge Acquisition

3.1.2 Special Requirements for Representing Strategic Knowledge

3.2 The Architecture: MU

3.2.1 The Structure and Function of MU

3.2.2 The Inference Network

3.2.3 Control Features

3.3 The Language: Strategy Rules

3.3.1 Focus Rules

3.3.2 Filter Rules

3.3.3 Selection Rules

3.3.4 Rule Matching and the Control Cycle

3.3.5 Precedence Among Rules: Shadowing

3.3.6 Shadowing Versus Weighted-sum Preference Models

3.3.7 An Example: Choosing a Diagnostic Question

3.4 Other Representations of Strategy

3.4.1 Procedural Formulations

3.4.2 Control Rules and Metarules

3.4.3 Blackboard-based Control

3.4.4 Strategy as Decision Making

3.4.5 Summary of Alternate Representations

4. The Ask Knowledge Acquisition Assistant

4.1 Functional Objectives for the Knowledge Acquisition Assistant

4.2 The Ask Knowledge Acquisition Procedure

4.2.1 Eliciting Feedback on System Performance

4.2.2 Eliciting the User's Preferences

4.2.3 Analyzing the Discrepancy with Existing Strategic Knowledge

4.2.4 Eliciting Justifications for Actions

4.2.5 Formulating New Strategy Rules

4.2.6 Generalizing Strategy Rules

4.2.7 Verifying Strategy Rules

4.3 The Elicitation of Justifications

4.3.1 The Justification Interface

4.3.2 Seeding the Justifications

4.3.3 The New Term Interface

4.4 Learning Strategy Rules

4.4.1 The Learning Task

4.4.2 Credit Assignment

4.4.3 Operationalization: Formulating a New Strategy Rule

4.4.4 Moving Tests into Generators

4.4.5 Generalization 1: Turning Constants into Variables

4.4.6 Generalization 2: Extending Reference

4.4.7 Generalizations: Dropping Conditions

4.5 Ask as a Computer Program

4.5.1 The Software Infrastructure

4.5.2 The User Interface

5. Approaches to Knowledge Acquisition

5.1 Preliminaries

5.1.1 The Stages of Knowledge Acquisition

5.1.2 Three Paradigms of Research in Knowledge Acquisition

5.2 The Engineering Approach to Knowledge Acquisition

5.2.1 Improvements in the Analysis Stages of Knowledge Acquisition

5.2.2 Knowledge System Development Tools

5.2.3 Task-specific Architectures

5.3 Model-based Elicitation Tools

5.4 Machine Learning

5.4.1 Similarity-based Learning

5.4.2 Explanation-based Learning

5.4.3 Case-based Learning

5.5 Hybrid Approaches: Learning with Human Guidance

5.5.1 Similarity-based Induction of Control Knowledge with Human Guidance

5.5.2 Inducing Control Plans from Sequences of Actions

5.5.3 Integrating Knowledge Elicitation and Inductive Generalization

5.6 Conclusions Drawn from the Literature

6. Experience with Ask

6.1 Acquiring Strategy from Physicians

6.1.1 Sessions with the Experts

6.1.2 The Initial Strategy Rules

6.1.3 Case 1: Building a Rule from Seeded Justifications

6.1.4 Case 2: Success at Defining a New Feature

6.1.5 Case 3: Failure - Producing an Overly-general Filter Rule

6.1.6 Analysis of the Chest Pain Domain

6.1.7 Application of the Chest Pain Strategy to a Plant Pathology Problem

6.2 Reacquiring the Complete MUM Strategy

6.2.1 MUM's Strategic Phase Planner

6.2.2 Representing a General Diagnostic Strategy in Hand-coded Rules

6.2.3 Reacquiring the General Strategy using ASK

6.3 Acquiring a Strategy for Controlling Fire-fighting Agents

6.3.1 Modeling the Reactions of Agents

6.4 Reimplementing the Neomycin Diagnostic Strategy

7. Evaluation and Discussion

7.1 A Perspective on Evaluation

7.2 Scope of Applicability: Characteristics of Suitable Tasks

7.2.1 Actions can be Selected One at a Time

7.2.2 Actions can be Modeled as Primitive Steps

7.2.3 Local Action-selection Criteria Avoid Global Pitfalls

7.2.4 An Optimal Decision Among Actions is not Possible or not Necessary

7.2.5 Features can be Measured on Absolute Scales

7.3 Sources of Power in Ask

7.3.1 Interactive Acquisition in the Context of Performance

7.3.2 Model-based Knowledge Acquisition

7.3.3 Explicit, Declarative Representation of Control

7.3.4 Fine-grained Control and Local Decisions

7.3.5 Generalizability of the Representation

7.3.6 Reformulating Strategy as Classification

7.3.7 Integrating Machine Learning and Interactive Knowledge Acquisition

7.4 Assumptions and Limitations of Ask

7.4.1 Strategic Choices Contribute to Expert Performance

7.4.2 Experts'Justifications are a Valid Basis for Strategy

7.4.3 Substantive Knowledge must be Acquired and Correct

7.4.4 Dependence on Knowledge Engineers

7.4.5 Efficiency Concerns

7.4.6 Multiple Experts

7.5 A Summary

8. Conclusions and Conjectures

8.1 The Acquirability Trade-off

8.2 Integrating Induction and Elicitation

8.3 Design for Knowledge Acquisition

8.4 Impact of Automated Knowledge Acquisition on Knowledge Engineering Practice

8.5 Explanation as a Medium for Knowledge Acquisition

Appendix 1: A Strategy for Prospective Diagnosis

Appendix 2: Acquiring a Strategy from Scratch




No. of pages:
© Academic Press 1989
28th November 1989
Academic Press
eBook ISBN:

About the Author

Thomas R. Gruber

Ratings and Reviews