# Relation Algebras by Games, Volume 147

## 1st Edition

**Authors:**Robin Hirsch Ian Hodkinson

**eBook ISBN:**9780080540450

**Hardcover ISBN:**9780444509321

**Imprint:**North Holland

**Published Date:**15th August 2002

**Page Count:**710

**View all volumes in this series:**Studies in Logic and the Foundations of Mathematics

## Table of Contents

Preface.

Foreword.

1 Introduction.

1.1 History.

1.2 To the games.

1.3 Non-finite axiomatisability.

1.4 Approximations to representability.

1.5 Constructions of algebras.

1.6 Some remarks on methods.

1.7 Summary of contents

I Algebras of Relations.

2 Preliminaries.

2.1 Foundations.

2.2 Model theory.

2.2.1 Syntax.

2.2.2 Semantics - structures.

2.2.3 Models, validity.

2.2.4 Homomorphisms, embeddings, substructures.

2.2.5 Generating sets.

2.2.6 Compactness, Lowenheim-Skolem-Tarski theorems.

2.2.7 Relativisation, interpretations, second-order logic.

2.3 Boolean algebras.

2.3.1 Definition and examples.

2.3.2 Atoms.

2.3.3 Dense sets.

2.3.4 Ideals, filters, ultrafilters.

2.3.5 Representations of boolean algebras.

2.3.6 Canonical extensions.

2.3.7 Infinite sums and products.

2.3.8 Complete representations.

2.3.9 Completions of boolean algebras.

2.4 Products and ultraproducts.

2.4.1 Products.

2.4.2 Ultraproducts, ultrapowers.

2.5 Boolean algebras with operators.

2.5.1 Definitions.

2.5.2 Homomorphisms and ideals.

2.5.3 Completely additive and conjugated algebras.

2.5.4 Completions of BAOs.

2.6 Varieties and quasi-varieties of BAOs.

2.6.1 Basic concepts.

2.6.2 HSP notation and Birkhoff's theorem.

2.6.3 Subdirect products.

2.6.4 Discriminator varieties.

2.7 Aspects of duality for BAOs.

2.7.1 Atom structures of BAOs.

2.7.2 Complex algebras.

2.7.3 Canonical (perfect) extensions of BAOs.

2.7.4 Axiomatising the atom structures of a variety.

2.7.5 Recovering a variety from its atom structures?

2.7.6 Sahlqvist varieties

3 Binary relations and relation algebra.

3.1 Algebraic logic.

3.2 Binary relations.

3.2.1 Proper relation algebras.

3.2.2 Square proper relation algebras.

3.3 Relation algebras.

3.3.1 Definition of relation algebras.

3.3.2 Peircean law.

3.3.3 RA is a completely additive variety of BAOs.

3.3.4 RA is a canonical variety.

3.3.5 RA is a discriminator variety.

3.3.6 Atom structures of relation algebras.

3.3.7 Consistent and forbidden triples of atoms.

3.4 Representations of relation algebras.

3.4.1 The class RRA.

3.4.2 Model-theoretic view of representations.

3.4.3 Saturation.

3.4.4 RRA is a canonical variety

4 Examples of relation algebras.

4.1 Set algebras.

4.2 Group relation algebras.

4.3 n-variable logic.

4.4 Examples.

4.5 The Lyndon algebras.

5 Relativisation and cylindric algebras.

5.1 Relativisation.

5.1.1 Relativised representations.

5.1.2 Non-associative algebras.

5.1.3 Weakly associative algebras.

5.1.4 Semi-associative algebras.

5.1.5 Basic facts about NA, WA, SA.

5.2 Weakly representable relation algebras.

5.3 Cylindric algebras.

5.4 Substitutions in cylindric algebras.

5.4.1 Basic facts about substitutions.

5.4.2 More valid substitution-cylindrification identities.

5.5 Relativised cylindric algebras.

5.6 Relation algebra reducts of cylindric algebras.

5.6.1 Neat reducts and relation algebra reducts.

5.6.2 Relation algebra reducts and canonical extensions.

5.6.3 Relation algebra reducts are relation algebras.

5.6.4 The classes SNr(beta)CA(alpha) and SRaCA(n).

5.7 Relation algebra reducts of other cylindric-type algebras

.

6 Other approaches to algebras of relations.

6.1 Diagonal-free algebras.

6.2 Polyadic algebra.

6.3 Pinter's substitution algebras.

6.4 Finitisation problem.

6.4.1 Reducts, subreducts, generalised subreducts.

6.4.2 Expansions.

6.4.3 Special conditions for representability.

6.5 Decidability.

6.6 Amalgamation.

6.7 Technical innovations.

6.8 Applications

II Games.

7 Games and networks.

7.1 Networks.

7.2 Refining networks.

7.3 All weakly associative algebras have relativised representations.

7.4 Games on relation algebra networks.

7.5 Strategies.

7.6 Games and representations of relation algebras.

7.7 Networks for cylindric algebras.

7.8 Games for cylindric algebra networks.

7.9 Games for temporal constraint handling.

7.10 Summary of chapter

8 Axiomatising representable relation algebras and cylindric algebras.

8.1 The relation algebra case.

8.2 An axiomatisation using 'Q-operators'.

8.2.1 The new function symbols.

8.2.2 Equations using these function symbols.

8.2.3 Proof that the equations characterise representability.

8.2.4 The Jonsson Q-operators.

8.3 Axiomatising RCA(d) for 3 d omega.

8.4 Axiomatising RCA(alpha) for infinite alpha

9 Axiomatising pseudo-elementary classes.

9.1 Introduction.

9.2 Pseudo-elementary classes.

9.3 Examples.

9.4 Model theory of pseudo-elementary classes.

9.4.1 Alternative single-sorted view.

9.4.2 Equivalence of sorted and unsorted approaches.

9.4.3 Survey of known results.

9.5 More explicit axioms.

9.5.1 The game.

9.5.2 The game characterises K.

9.5.3 Short games.

9.5.4 Axioms for the short games.

9.5.5 The axioms define K.

9.5.6 Varieties and equations.

9.6 Axiomatising pseudo-elementary classes.

9.7 Generalised Q-operators

10 Game trees.

10.1 Trees, and games on them.

10.2 Strategies.

10.3 Examples.

10.3.1 The game Gn(Ia,A).

10.4 Formulas expressing a winning strategy.

10.5 Games and non-finite axiomatisability.

10.5.1 Ultraproducts and games.

10.5.2 Countable, elementary subalgebra.

10.5.3 Non-finite axiomatisability

11 Atomic networks.

11.1 Introduction.

11.2 Atomic networks and games.

11.3 Alternative views of the game.

11.3.1 Relation to the game Gn of chapter 7.

11.3.2 Lyndon conditions.

11.3.3 Game tree view.

11.4 Atomic games and complete representations.

11.5 Axioms for complete representability?

III Approximations.

12 Relational, cylindric, and hyperbases.

12.1 Hypernetworks.

12.1.1 Definition of hypernetworks.

12.1.2 Comparing and altering hypernetworks.

12.2 Relational bases and hyperbases.

12.2.1 Relational bases.

12.2.2 Hyperbases.

12.3 Elementary properties of bases.

12.3.1 Symmetric bases.

12.3.2 Interpolation in hyperbases.

12.3.3 From hyperbasis to cylindric algebra.

12.3.4 Reducing the dimension of a relational basis.

12.3.5 Reducing the dimension of a hyperbasis.

12.4 Games.

12.4.1 Game for relational bases.

12.4.2 Game for hyperbases.

12.4.3 Expressing the games by game trees.

12.5 The variety RA(n).

12.6 Maddux's bases.

12.6.1 Relational and cylindric bases.

12.6.2 Comparing cylindric bases with hyperbases.

12.7 Cylindric bases and homogeneous representations

13 Approximations to RRA.

13.1 Representation theory.

13.1.1 Relativised semantics for L(A).

13.1.2 Square relativised representations.

13.1.3 Flat relativised representations.

13.1.4 Smooth relativised representations.

13.1.5 Links between the notions.

13.1.6 Elementary view.

13.2 From relativised representations to relation algebra reducts.

13.3 From reducts to relational bases.

13.4 From reducts to hyperbases.

13.4.1 Preliminary results on substitutions.

13.4.2 Finding the hyperbasis.

13.5 From bases to relativised representations.

13.6 From smooth to hyperbasis.

13.7 Summary and discussion.

13.7.1 Atomic non-associative algebras.

13.7.2 Arbitrary non-associative algebras.

13.7.3 Three-dimensional version of theorem 13.46.

13.7.4 Finite versions of theorem 13.46 (first part).

13.7.5 Finite versions of theorem 13.46 (second part).

13.8 Equational axioms for RA(n) and SRaCA(n)

IV Constructing Relation Algebras.

14 Strongly representable relation algebra atom structures 4.

14.1 Introduction.

14.2 SRAS is not an elementary class.

14.2.1 Graphs and colourings.

14.2.2 The construction.

14.2.3 SRAS is not elementary.

14.3 Consequences of the theorem.

14.3.1 Closure properties.

14.3.2 Related classes.

14.4 Maddux's construction.

14.4.1 The atom structures.

14.4.2 X(q) is strongly representable

15 Non-finite axiomatisability of SRaCA(n+1) over SRaCA(n).

15.1 Outline of chapter.

15.2 The algebras A(n,r) and C(r).

15.3 A(n,r) in SRaCA(n).

15.4 A(n,r) not in SRaCA(n+1).

15.5 E can win G(m,n+1;r)(A(n,r),L).

15.6 Non-finite axiomatisability.

15.7 Proof theory

16 The rainbow construction for relation algebras.

16.1 Ehrenfeucht-Fraisse `forth' games.

16.1.1 The standard Ehrenfeucht-Fraisse game.

16.1.2 The modified Ehrenfeucht-Fraisse game.

16.2 The rainbow algebra A(A,B).

16.3 How A can win G(A(A,B)).

16.4 How E can win G(A(A,B)).

16.5 Modifications to the rainbow algebra

17 Applying the rainbow construction.

17.1 Non-finite axiomatisability of RRA.

17.2 Complete representations.

17.3 There is no n-variable equational axiomatisation of RRA.

17.4 RA(n+1) is not finitely based over RA(n).

17.5 Infinite-dimensional bases and relativised representations.

17.6 Weakly representable relation algebras.

17.7 Completions.

17.7.1 The example.

17.7.2 Corollaries and problems

V Decidability.

18 Undecidability of the representation problem for finite algebras.

18.1 Introduction.

18.2 The tiling problem.

18.3 The definition of RA(t).

18.4 Games.

18.5 Winning E-strategy implies tiling

18.6 RA(t) in SRaCA(5) implies tiling

18.7 Tiling implies winning E-strategy

18.7.1 E's strategy for non-tile edges

18.7.2 Tile edges

18.7.3 Attached and linked tile edges

18.7.4 Inductive conditions T1, T2, T3 on N

18.7.5 Tiling functions and coordinates for A's tile edges

18.7.6 Tiling functions for E's new tile edges

18.7.7 Coordinates for E's new tile edges

18.7.8 Conditions T1, T2 hold for M

18.7.9 E's strategy for tile edges, T3, and consistency

18.8 Conclusion

18.9 Weak representability is undecidable

18.10 Undecidability of equational theories

19 Finite base property

19.1 Introduction

19.2 Guarded fragments

19.2.1 Loosely guarded fragment

19.2.2 Packed fragment

19.2.3 Clique-guarded fragment

19.2.4 Finite model property

19.3 The finite base property

19.4 Finite base property for WA

19.5 Finite algebra on finite base property for RA(n)

19.6 The finite algebra on finite base property for SRaCA(n)?

VI Epilogue

20 Brief summary

20.1 Basic definitions

20.2 Games for representability

20.3 Relativised representations, bases, reducts

20.3.1 Relativised representations

20.3.2 Relational bases and hyperbases

20.3.3 Relation algebra reducts

20.3.4 Equivalences between the notions

20.4 The rainbow construction

20.5 Atom structures

20.6 Decidability

20.7 Summary of relations between the classes

20.8 Summary of properties of classes

21 Problems

Bibliography

Symbol index

Subject index

## Description

Relation algebras are algebras arising from the study of binary relations. They form a part of the field of algebraic logic, and have applications in proof theory, modal logic, and computer science. This research text uses combinatorial games to study the fundamental notion of representations of relation algebras. Games allow an intuitive and appealing approach to the subject, and permit substantial advances to be made. The book contains many new results and proofs not published elsewhere. It should be invaluable to graduate students and researchers interested in relation algebras and games.

After an introduction describing the authors' perspective on the material, the text proper has six parts. The lengthy first part is devoted to background material, including the formal definitions of relation algebras, cylindric algebras, their basic properties, and some connections between them. Examples are given. Part 1 ends with a short survey of other work beyond the scope of the book. In part 2, games are introduced, and used to axiomatise various classes of algebras. Part 3 discusses approximations to representability, using bases, relation algebra reducts, and relativised representations. Part 4 presents some constructions of relation algebras, including Monk algebras and the 'rainbow construction', and uses them to show that various classes of representable algebras are non-finitely axiomatisable or even non-elementary. Part 5 shows that the representability problem for finite relation algebras is undecidable, and then in contrast proves some finite base property results. Part 6 contains a condensed summary of the book, and a list of problems. There are more than 400 exercises.

The book is generally self-contained on relation algebras and on games, and introductory text is scattered throughout. Some familiarity with elementary aspects of first-order logic and set theory is assumed, though many of the definitions are given. Chapter 2 introduces the necessary universal algebra and model theory, and more specific model-theoretic ideas are explained as they arise.

## Details

- No. of pages:
- 710

- Language:
- English

- Copyright:
- © North Holland 2002

- Published:
- 15th August 2002

- Imprint:
- North Holland

- eBook ISBN:
- 9780080540450

- Hardcover ISBN:
- 9780444509321

## Reviews

@qu:This unique approach to the study of algebraic logic, to a large extent pioneered by the authors, contrasts with the developments based extensively on universal algebra that are found most often in the literature. the book is well written and not only provides a valuable resource to researchers, but is accessible to graduate students and mathematicians in related areas. Extensive intuitive motivation for the techniques and arguments are provided in addition to technical details. @source:Mathematical Reviews @qu:This book is a significant advance in the theory of relation algebras. Many of its main results solve difficult and long-standing problems. Its methods, techniques, and constructions are powerful tools for exploring the intricate and varied world of relation algebras. Its many open problems indicate fruitful directions for further research. @source:Logic Journal of the Interest Group in Pure and Applied Logic, Vol. 11, Issue 5, Sept. 2003 "This book is a significant advance in the theory of relation algebras. Many of its main resultssolve difficult an lond-standing problems." Roger Maddux, (Ames), in: (Zentralblatt für Mathematik, p.4, Vol. 1018, 2004) "...for Relation Algebras by Games is indeed a source of intellectual delight, treating its topic in a manner befitting its intrinsic charm and beauty." Maarten Marx, (University of Amsterdam),in: (Studia Logica, Vol. 76, 2004)

## Ratings and Reviews

## About the Authors

### Robin Hirsch Author

### Affiliations and Expertise

University College, London, UK

### Ian Hodkinson Author

### Affiliations and Expertise

Imperial College, London, UK