Guide for Authors
Queries about submission requirements may be addressed to either of the managing editors:
Sandra Perrine
perrine@ajog.phxcoxmail.com
965 W. Hackberry Ct.
Chandler, AZ 85248
Phone 480-812-9261
Fax 480-812-9409
Donna L. Stroud
ajog@rrohio.com
5228 Bressler Dr.
Hilliard, OH 43026
Phone 614-527-3820
Fax 614-527-3821
EDITORIAL POLICIES
Submission
Authors must submit manuscripts online at
www.ees.elsevier.com/ajog.
Hard copy submissions will NOT be considered or returned. All policies of the
American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology,
particularly with regard to Conflicts of Interest, Inappropriate Acts, and IRB approval, also apply to abstracts presented at Society
meetings and published in this Journal as a result of the proceedings.
Submitted manuscripts will first be screened by the journal
staff and editors. Because of the large number of papers submitted for consideration, it is important for the Journal to process submissions
in a timely fashion. Many papers are turned away based on this in-house screening alone, and authors will be notified of the decision
promptly. For many papers, an immediate decision is made to decline without further peer review. All other papers are sent out for peer
review.
Ethics of the editorial process
Specific
Inappropriate Acts in the Publication Process (also available at
www.AJOG.org)
describes the Journal's policies regarding the ethical practices, which apply to all submitted articles, whether accepted for publication
or not.
Authors are advised to review this document prior to submission.
Noncompliance with any of the provisions
of this policy may lead to an investigation and to an editorial judgment regarding these policies. Besides describing issues such as
plagiarism and falsification of data, the document contains information regarding duplicate publication of which all prospective authors
must be aware. If a report by any or all of the same author(s) has previously been published in any medium that deals in any respect
whatsoever with the same patients, animals, laboratory experiments, or data, in part or in full, as those reported in the manuscript
being submitted, a reprint of the published article(s) or a copy of the final manuscript must be uploaded with the submitted manuscript.
Additionally, a current copy of any new manuscript being prepared for possible publication must be provided. The author(s) are to inform
the editors in detail about the circumstances surrounding the reports as well as their similarities and differences.
The same requirement
applies to the submission of a manuscript in which additional patients, animals, laboratory experiments, or data were added to those
reported in a previous publication, submission or accepted manuscript. Articles previously published in another language will not be
considered for publication in the Journal.
Previous submission (unpublished)
If the manuscript was previously submitted
elsewhere and not accepted, the authors may, if they wish, provide a copy of the peer review comments and a detailed response to each
point.
Human and nonhuman experimentation
Authors must follow the ethical standards for human experimentation established
in the Declaration of Helsinki (World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki: recommendations guiding physicians in biomedical research
involving human subjects. JAMA 1997;277:925-6). The editors assume that a manuscript emanating from a particular institution is submitted
with the approval of the requisite authority. The authors of reports of human experimentation that requires local institutional approval
must have obtained this approval
before the experiment was started.
Upon request of the Journal editors, the author(s)
are required to provide copies of the appropriate documentation. Institutional approval must be indicated in the Materials and Methods
section of the submitted manuscript. If the study is exempt from Institutional Review Board approval, an explanation must be provided
under Materials and Methods.
For reports of experiments on nonhuman animals or other species, authors must state in the Materials
and Methods section of the manuscript that guidelines for the care and use of the animals approved by the local institution were followed.
The type(s) of nonhuman animals or other species used in an investigation must be named in the Title, Abstract, Key Words, and Materials
and Methods sections of the manuscript.
Trial and research guidelines
The following guidelines must be adhered to when
formulating the study. Upon submitting the manuscript, authors are to indicate on the Submission Checklist the type of trial/research
used.
•
Randomized controlled trial. Authors are to consult the revised
CONSORT
statement (Moher D, Schulz KF, Altman D, for the CONSORT Group. The CONSORT Statement: revised recommendations for improving
the quality of reports of parallel-group randomized trials. JAMA 2001;285:1987-91). A flowchart as a figure must be submitted in the
manuscript.
•
Meta-analysis or systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Authors are to consult the
QUOROM statement (Moher D, Cook DJ, Eastwood S, Olkin I, Rennie D, Stroup DF,
for the QUOROM Group. Improving the quality of reports of meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials: the QUOROM statement. Quality
of Reporting of Meta-analyses. Lancet 1999;354:1896-1900).
•
Meta-analysis or systematic review of observational studies.
Authors are to consult the
MOOSE
guidelines (Stroup DF, Berlin JA, Morton SC, et al, for the Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology [MOOSE]
group. Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology: a proposal for reporting. JAMA 2000;283:2008-12).
•
Diagnostic
tests. Authors are to consult the
STARD
Initiative (Bossuyt PM, Reitsma JB, Bruns DE, et al., for the STARD Group. Towards complete and accurate reporting of studies
of diagnostic accuracy: the STARD
•
Health economics. In addition to the general instructions for authors and other guidelines
applicable to their study (eg, CONSORT guidelines for a randomized, controlled trial), authors of health economics manuscripts should
consider the following issues specific to such studies and address them in the manuscript and/or submission letter. A
health economics checklist is to be included with the general manuscript checklist at the time
of submission.
Authorship
Each author must qualify by having participated actively and sufficiently in the study reported.
The inclusion of each author in the authorship list of a report must be based only on 1) substantial contributions to (a) the concept
and design, or analysis and interpretation of data and (b) the author's having drafted the manuscript or revised it critically for important
intellectual content; and 2) final approval by each author of the version of the manuscript being submitted. All conditions (1a, 1b,
and 2) must be met. Others contributing to the work, including participants in collaborative trials, should be recognized separately
in the Acknowledgment(s) section. In the cover letter that accompanies the submitted manuscript, it must be confirmed that all bylined
authors fulfill all conditions. Accordingly, authors are encouraged to limit the number of authors listed.
Conflict of interest
Authors are expected to address any potential conflict of interest in the cover letter of the submitted manuscript. Such potential
conflicts include any financial interest by the authors in a company producing products described in the submitted manuscript as well
as stock, stock options, direct employment, consulting status, or membership in a speaker's' bureau. If an author owns stock in the company
valued at $10,000 or more, or is employed by the company, either full time or part time, this should be stated in the cover letter.
The monetary value of any such stock holdings should be named. Failure to do so may result in sanctions. If the manuscript is accepted,
the editor in consultation with the author will decide what potential conflicts must be disclosed to the reader on the first page of
the article. Such information is confidential, is not given to the reviewers, and does not play a part in the decision of the quality
or timeliness of the manuscript. No policy could cover every contingency that might be construed as a conflict of interest. Therefore,
it is the hope and preference of the editors that if any possibility of a conflict of interest exists when authors submit a paper, the
authors reveal this situation to the editors to allow us to determine whether readers should be so informed when the article is published.
If the editors determine that no conflict exists, no such notification will be published with the article. The usual and customary listing
of sources of support and institutional affiliations on the title page is proper and does not imply a conflict of interest.
Disclaimer
Statements and opinions expressed in articles and communications therein are those of the author(s) and not necessarily
those of the editors or publisher. The editors and publisher disclaim any responsibility or liability for such material. Neither the
editors nor the publisher guarantees, warrants, or endorses any product or service advertised in this publication, nor do they guarantee
any claim made by the manufacturer of such product or service.
Copyright statement
Upon acceptance, the publisher will
require a signed copyright statement.
Permissions
Direct quotations, tables, or figures that have appeared in copyrighted
material must be accompanied by written permission for their use from the copyright owner and original author along with complete reference
information. Photographs of identifiable persons must be accompanied by signed releases; if not, all recognizable features must be masked.
Submission checklist
The
submission checklist must be completed in full by the author(s) and included with the submitted manuscript. A complete
description of each item to be checked is provided under the appropriate heading.
If the checklist is not completed in full, the submission
will not be considered.
Suggested reviewers
Upon submitting a manuscript, authors are required to provide the name,
address, and e-mail address of at least 3 potential reviewers for editorial consideration. Suggested reviewers may include anyone knowledgeable
in the area of study presented. Authors should not knowingly recommend as a potential reviewer a person with a potential conflict of
interest, either financial or personal (positive or negative bias), such as a mentor or close associate. Additionally, the authors should
not recommend any individuals located at the same institution as any of the authors.
Reprints
The publisher will send
reprint-ordering information directly to the corresponding author of articles accepted for publication during the production process.
REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PREPARATION OF A MANUSCRIPT
The requirements for manuscripts submitted to the Journal generally conform
to the
Uniform Requirements for Manuscripts Submitted to Biomedical Journals,
established by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (www.icmje.org). Manuscripts must be submitted in English, with
a font size no smaller than 12. Number pages consecutively in the upper right-hand corner in the following order: title page, condensation,
abstract, text, acknowledgments, references, figure legends, and tables.
The author(s) accept(s) responsibility that the electronic
file is complete and accurate upon submission, revision, and acceptance.
Basic format
-
Title page (page 1)
The title page (page 1) should contain, in the following sequence: the title (concise and suitable for indexing purposes; conclusion
statements should NOT be included); author line, including each author's first name, middle initial, and LAST NAME (surname in all capital
letters), with highest academic degrees (MD, PhD, MPH, and the like may all be used, but honorary degrees are not permitted); city or
cities, state(s), and country or countries other than the United States in which the study was conducted; divisional and/or departmental
and institutional affiliations at the time the study was performed; source(s) of financial support, if any; presentation information
(if the findings of the submission were presented at a meeting, include the name of the meeting, the organization presenting the meeting,
the city and state or city and non-US country, in which the meeting was held, and the day, month, and year of the presentation); disclaimers,
if any; the name of the individual responsible for reprint requests, along with his/her contact information; full mailing address, email
address or both (if reprints will not be available, this should be so stated); and the name, address, business and home telephone numbers,
fax number, and email address of the author responsible for correspondence related to the manuscript.
Word count
The
word counts of both the abstract and the text (excluding references) should be stated in the lower left corner of the title page and
on the checklist.
Condensation (page 2)
Page 2 of the manuscript should contain a 1-sentence condensation of the paper,
double spaced, and consisting of no more than 25 words, that briefly and concisely states its essential point(s). This sentence, which
is subject to copy editing to conform with Journal style, will appear in the Table of Contents.
Abstract page, including key
words/phrases (page 3)
Page 3 of the manuscript should consist of the abstract, double spaced, preceded by the title of the
article and the name(s) of the author(s). Below the abstract, list 3 to 5 key words or short phrases, alphabetized, for indexing purposes.
Abstract formats
-
Research articles
A structured abstract of no more than 150 words should contain
the following major headings:
- • Objective(s): Reflects the purpose of the study (the hypothesis that
is being tested).
-
• Study Design: The setting for the study, the subjects (number and type), the
treatment or intervention, and the type of statistical analysis used.
- • Results: The outcome(s)
of the study and, if appropriate, its/their statistical significance.
-
• Conclusion(s): The significance
of the results.
-
Case Reports and Clinical Opinion papers
A 1-paragraph unstructured abstract for
a Case Report should contain no more than 50 words. An unstructured abstract for a Clinical Opinion should contain 50 to 150 words.
Abbreviations
Abbreviations are not acceptable in the title and should be avoided, if possible, in the abstract.
In the text they should be kept to a practical minimum. The full word or phrase for which an abbreviation stands should precede its
first use in the text unless it is a conventional standard unit of measurement. Conventional units of measure are recommended, with Système
International (SI) units shown in parentheses. Only standard abbreviations may be used. For this and other issues of style, authors
are advised to consult the AMA style manual (Iverson C, Christiansen S, Flanagin A, et al.
AMA Manual of Style: A Guide for Authors
and Editors. 10th ed. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2007).
Text
The editors recommend that Research articles
be organized into sections identified with the following headings:
•
Introduction. State concisely the purpose of
the study and the rationale for the study. Present only the background, supported by a limited number of pertinent references, necessary
for the reader to understand why the study was conducted. The introduction should not include any data or conclusions from the current
study.
•
Materials and Methods. Describe briefly, but in sufficient detail to permit others to replicate the study the
plan, patients, experimental animals or other species, materials, and controls; methods and procedures; and statistical method(s) employed.
Institutional Review Board issues are to be addressed here as stated in the section of this document entitled Human and Nonhuman
Experimentation above. If the study was exempt from Institutional Review Board approval, an explanation should be provided under Materials
and Methods. The generic, chemical, or proprietary names of drugs may be used. If the generic or chemical name is used, authors may,
if they desire, insert the proprietary name in parentheses after the first mention in the text. When a proprietary drug name is used,
it should be followed parenthetically (at first mention only) by the full name of the manufacturer and the city and state (US) or city
and country (non-US) in which its main headquarters are located. Do not insert the symbols for registered trademark (®) or trademark
(™); if they are included, they will be removed before publication.
•
Results. This section includes detailed
findings and must cite all tables and/or figures, which should supplement, not repeat, the text-Emphasize only the most important observations;
do not compare your observations with those of others. Such comparisons and comments are reserved for the Comment section.
•
Comment.
Do not repeat the details of data presented under Results or present any new data here. The editors strongly advise that the Comment
section be structured as follows:
-
• A brief statement of the principal findings, limiting any claims to those strictly
supported by the data, avoiding speculation and overgeneralization. Give equal emphasis to positive and negative findings of equal scientific
merit.
- • Strengths and weaknesses of the study.
- • Strengths and weaknesses of the study in relation
to other studies, discussing particularly any differences in results.
- • Meaning of the study: eg,hypothesized mechanisms
that might explain the outcomes observed and/or the implications for clinicians or policy makers. Indicate whether additional research
is required before the information is used in clinical settings.
- • Unanswered questions and proposals for future research.
Use of statistics
In describing the statistical analyses that have been performed, authors must clearly state which tests
were used to evaluate a specific data set. When data are presented in tabular form, the statistical test used to evaluate the data should
be indicated with a footnote for each test used.
Acknowledgment(s)
Only persons who have made substantive contributions
to the study should be named in this section.
References
Reference format should follow that in the
Uniform
Requirements for Manuscripts Submitted to Biomedical Journals (www.icmje.org). Use journal title abbreviations as in the
List of Journals Indexed for MEDLINE.
• Published abstracts may be used, although a reference to the complete published article, if available, is preferred.
•
Websites may or may not be an appropriate means of citation; eg, websites that serve as repositories of genetic information maintained
by NIH, NCI, or the National Library of Medicine are acceptable.
• Provisional patent applications are unacceptable.
-
Numbering and order
-
• All references are to be numbered sequentially as they fall in the text. Any
references cited only within table(s) or figure(s) should be numbered in the order in which those tables and/or figures fall in the main
text, with the first of the table/figure reference numbers to follow the last number used in the reference list for the main text. Citations
are to be inserted in Arabic numerals, superscripted, not in parentheses. If the reference falls at the end of a sentence, the superscript
should follow the period at the end of the sentence. The surname of the first author of the cited reference should not be included, in
parentheses or otherwise, except as desired within the text (Smith et al. found...).
-
• Authors must type the reference
numbers in the reference list individually. Automatic reference numbering software is unacceptable.
-
• If any reference
is repeated or out of order, the author is responsible for renumbering all subsequent references prior to submission or resubmission.
Additionally, should any reference(s) be added or deleted, the author is responsible for renumbering all subsequent references, both
in citations within the text (and tables and figures) and, correspondingly, in the reference list at the end.
-
Examples
(for up to 6 authors, list all; for 7 or more authors, list 3+ et al):
-
• Journal article. Brosens JJ, Pijnenborg
R, Brosens IA. The myometrial junctional zone spiral arteries in normal and abnormal pregnancies. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2002;187:1416-23.
-
• Book chapter. Kim M. Amenorrhea: primary and secondary. In: Zuspan FP, Quilligan ED, eds. Handbook of
obstetrics, gynecology, and primary care. St. Louis: Mosby; 1998:3-10.
-
• Personal communications and unpublished
data. If essential, these may be used, within parentheses, at the appropriate location in the text, not as numbered references.
Written, signed permission from the individuals(s) quoted must accompany the manuscript upon submission.
Figures,
tables, videos, and computer graphics
-
Figures
Submit figures online, each in a separate file, not embedded in
the manuscript document. Cite figures consecutively, as they appear in the text, with Arabic numbers (Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3A,
etc.). Each figure must be assigned a brief title (as few words as possible) as well as a legend. Explanatory material, such as abbreviations,
belongs in the legend, not the title.
Figure legend page
Legends should appear on a separate page, not with each
figure. The legend page is to be numbered in sequence after the last page of the references list. List all figures sequentially, as
they appear in the text, with Arabic numerals (Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3A, etc.), and accompanied by a 1- or 2-sentence description.
Any symbol, arrowhead, or letter used to identify parts of a photograph, drawing, or other illustration must be explained. Any abbreviations
must be spelled out. If appropriate, explain the internal scale and identify the method of staining in photomicrographs. If a figure
was previously published by you or others, a statement that permission has been granted and by whom should appear in the figure legend,
as should a full citation of the original site of publication.
Tables
Submit tables in separate files, not embedded
in the manuscript. Tables are to be double spaced and numbered sequentially, with Arabic numbers (Table 1, Table 2, etc.), in order of
text citation. Each column, including the first, must have a heading. Provide a brief title for each table. Put all explanatory matter
in footnotes, including the spelling out of any nonstandard abbreviations used in the table. If a table, in whole or in part, was derived
from copyrighted material, a footnote at the bottom of the table must credit the original source, cited fully. When using copyrighted
material, submit a completed permission form or letter with the manuscript. Footnote symbols within tables should be used in the
order noted on pages 90-95 of the AMA style guide, 10th edition. For placement, start in the upper left corner and work across, left
to right, and down, line by line.
Videos and computer graphics
Authors are encouraged to submit videos and computer-generated
graphics; eg, a slide presentation with or without animation and sound. An author who wishes to supply such material should notify the
editors in the cover letter and note this intention in the Author Comments area of the online submission. Although the publisher will
not edit any video or computer graphic, the editors and reviewers may suggest changes. All patient-identifying information must be removed
or masked.
The maximum length of a video or computer graphic is 8 minutes. Longer submissions may be divided into smaller clips, each
of which should be identified at the beginning of that section; eg, Video Clip 1, Graphic 1. A concise legend for each video clip or
computer graphic presentation must be included with the manuscript. Videos are to be submitted in MPEG-1 or MPEG-2 (*.mpg) or QuickTime
(*.mov) format. More detailed instructions can be found at
http://www.elsevier.com/artwork . Videos and computer graphics
accompanying a manuscript that is declined for publication will not be accepted separately. If the manuscript is accepted for publication,
the presentation will be archived at www.AJOG.org.
Publication format
Research and Clinical Opinion articles are published in 2 formats: 1) in an abbreviated form, as a summary
of the article, with 1 figure or table, in the printed Journal and 2) in full on the Journal website (
www.AJOG.org).
Case Reports and Residents' Articles are published online only. All articles remain fully citable and available to searches.
Authors
of Research and Clinical Opinion articles that have been accepted for publication are asked to highlight the most significant statements
in the article for use in the preparation of an abbreviated version of the article for the printed journal. To expedite publication,
authors are encouraged to permit a Journal-affiliated medical writer to produce the article summary, which will be submitted to the authors
for their review and approval prior to publication. Authors who prefer to produce the abbreviated version themselves will receive guidelines
to follow. Author-produced article summaries will be subject to editing for length and consistency and to conform with Journal style.
An online version of the full-length article is accessible to subscribers and available for citation before the print version is released.
Impact factors and other citation indices are based on the full-length online version. After publication, the print summary is posted
along with the full-length article on the Journal's website.
DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLE TYPES
The use of multimedia
components such as PowerPoint, additional images, or video clips is encouraged for all article types.
Research articles
While authorship is generally limited to 7, additional authors may be considered on an individual basis only if they have met all authorship
requirements (see Authorship, above). It is preferred that authors beyond 7 be listed at the end of the article in the Acknowledgments
section. Manuscripts of more than 3000 words will not be considered. Include a structured abstract of no more than 150 words and accompanied
by 3 to 5 alphabetized key words or short phrases for indexing purposes.
An abbreviated version of the article, containing no more
than 1 figure or table, will appear in print; the article in full, containing all figures and tables, will be published on the Journal's
website. The editors encourage authors to permit a Journal-affiliated medical writer to produce the abbreviated version, which will
be submitted to the authors for their review and approval before publication. Authors who prefer to produce the abbreviated version
themselves will receive guidelines. Such article summaries will be subject to editing for length and consistency and to conform with
Journal style.
Case Reports
Limited to 5 authors, and 700 words. Include: 1) a 1-paragraph unstructured abstract of no
more than 50 words; 2) 3 to 5 key words/phrases for indexing purposes; 3) a brief introduction; 4) 1 or more case descriptions, labeled
either Case Report (if the article discusses only 1 case) or Case 1, Case 2, etc.; and 5) a section headed Comment. Case Reports will
be published on the Journal's website only.
Clinical Opinion papers
Limited to 7 authors and 3000 words. Include an unstructured
abstract of 50 to 150 words and 3 to 5 key words/phrases for indexing purposes. A Clinical Opinion should not be a systematic review
of an extensively researched subject, but represent the authors' studied and balanced opinion on a specific issue of clinical importance
or controversy. An abbreviated version, containing no more than 1 figure or table, will appear in print; the article in full will be
published on the Journal's website. The editors encourage authors to permit a Journal-affiliated medical writer to produce the abbreviated
version, which will be submitted to the authors for their review and approval before publication. Authors who prefer to produce the
abbreviated version themselves will receive guidelines. Such article summaries will be subject to editing for length and consistency
and to conform with Journal style.
Images in Obstetrics; Images in Gynecology
An interesting image of clinical significance,
such as a clinical photograph or evidence of a diagnostic test (ultrasound scan, MRI film, slide, photomicrograph, DNA blot, or similar),
is accompanied by a case description of no more than 300 words. The manuscript should include: 1) a brief case presentation; 2) relevant
image(s) accompanied by a short description; 3) a description of management, results, and patient outcome; and 4) the solution. Images
will be published, in different forms, in both the printed Journal and online. The text of the print article should not exceed 300 words.
The online article may include more pictures and/or a more detailed explanation than the print article, but should not exceed 500 words,
and should be accompanied by no more than 5 references. The number of authors is limited to 3. The use of multimedia components such
as PowerPoint, additional images, or video clips is encouraged.
Surgeon's Corner
The article introduces a new surgical
technique, surgical instrument, or application of a standard surgical procedure. Surgeon's Corner will be published, in different forms,
in both the printed Journal and online. The online version will include a video clip and an explanation of the technique or instrument.
The print version will include a description of the clinical situation or video clip in 300 words or less. A sample picture may appear
in the print edition of the Journal, where readers will be referred to
www.AJOG.org
for the full article. The use of multimedia components such as PowerPoint, additional images, or video clips is encouraged.
Letters
to the Editors
Only submissions that reference an article published in the
American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology
will be considered for publication. Letters are published online only.
• Letters are to be submitted online no more than 3 months
after the date of the issue in which the related article appeared.
• Letters should be brief and contain no more than 400
words plus 1 to 4 references, one of which must cite the related Journal article. All data presented in the letter must be fully citable
and listed as a supporting reference. Letters should be double spaced and signed by no more than 3 authors.
• Include a title
page as outlined above under Requirements for the Preparation of Manuscripts.
• Letters are subject to minor editorial alterations
and may be shortened without the approval of the author(s). The editors routinely invite the author(s) of the related article to respond
in writing. Published Letters are accompanied by either a reply from the original author or the statement "Reply declined."
Review articles
Review articles are submitted upon invitation of the Journal editors.
Links
•
Submission Checklist
•
Special Instructions
for Authors of Health Economics Manuscripts
•
Conflict
of Interest document
•
Specific
Inappropriate Acts in the Publication Process
Updated August 2008