Study on threat to polar bear penises inspires media, tweets — and comic John Oliver
Pollution could be jeopardizing the reproduction of polar bears, scientists report in Environmental Research journal
By Lucy Goodchild van Hilten Posted on 22 April 2015
In recent years, the polar bear has become an icon of climate change, often being pictured standing on a shrinking piece of ice. But this time, the poor polar bear is facing a different challenge – a reproductive one.
“Pollution could cause polar bears to break their d*cks,” proclaimed John Oliver, speaking on HBO's award-winning TV show Last Week Tonight on Monday. While this is something of a simplification, he’s not far wrong, and he encourages viewers to remember the polar bears during their Earth Day celebrations.
In fact, Oliver was referring to a study in Environmental Research, a journal published by Elsevier. In the article, lead author Dr. Christian Sonne of the Arctic Research Centre (ARC) in Denmark and colleagues acknowledge the plight of the polar bear: "Polar bears have recently received considerable focus as a wildlife species impacted by climate change, since projected sea ice loss is argued to restrict their access to principal prey, such as ringed seals, during the autumn.
But the authors go on to examine an additional concern: that endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) are threatening polar bears’ ability to reproduce.
Pollutants are linked to lower penis bone density
EDCs – including polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) – are chemical pollutants that result from industrial processes. They are known to harm several different vital organs and tissues – including bone. As predators at the top of the food chain, polar bears consume high concentrations of PCBs, resulting in potentially high levels of the chemicals in their bodies.
Like gorillas, hedgehogs and otters, polar bears have a penis bone, called a bacula. They need the bone to mate successfully – it acts as a stiffener and also causes ovulation in the female polar bear. Because of this, the health of the bacula indicates the reproductive health of the polar bear.
The researchers analyzed bacula samples from 279 polar bears born between 1990 and 2000 and noted the bone mineral density (BMD). They plotted the figures against PCB concentrations recorded in the same locations at the same times, to assess whether there is a correlation between bone density and PCB concentration.
The results suggest that the higher the PCB pollution level, the lower the density of the polar bear’s penis bone. The bone becomes weaker at lower density, making it more likely to break and therefore reducing the polar bear’s ability to reproduce.
In their paper, the authors conclude:
Reductions in penile BMD could lead to increased risk of species extinction because of mating and subsequent fertilization failure as a result of weak penile bones and risk of fractures. Based on this, future studies should assess how polar bear subpopulations respond upon EDC exposure since information and understanding about their circumpolar reproductive health is vital for future conservation.
New polar bear threat sparks global media interest
So now the polar bear has something new to worry about: penis fractures and failing fertility. The research captured people’s imaginations, resulting in a flurry of media coverage. “You’ll Never Guess What Our Pollution Is Doing To Polar Bears’ Penises,” screamed the MTV News headline, explaining the science in the deckhead: “We're basically cock-blocking these cute, fluffy bears. Not cool.”
The headlines reflect the reason polar bears in trouble capture our attention: many people see them as “cute, fluffy” animals (they’re actually dangerous carnivores, but let’s not split hairs). Either way, they need our help. As the New Scientist put it: “First climate change, now penile fracture – polar bears have got it pretty rough.”
Social media was moved, too, with Tweets, Facebook posts and blogs talking about the findings:
Poor polar bears :( Will the indignities never cease? http://t.co/XwzTssZJwe— Thomas Bell (@RealThomasBell) January 26, 2015
Meanwhile @DanGraur looked on the bright side:
Aren't we lucky we don't have one: Pollution causes low bone densities and breaks in the penile bones of polar bears. http://t.co/YM7wVWGjeG— Dan Graur (@DanGraur) March 16, 2015
And @sparrk gave a shout-out to Elsevier:
Back on the set of Last Week Tonight, out comes Marshmallow – the polar bear with a broken penis. “Come on everyone, this Earth Day, I want you all to think of Marshmallow’s devastated penis,” Oliver implores. “Because while it may not be salvageable, others may still be.”
Read the study
Elsevier has made this study freely available for three months, until July 21, 2015:
Christian Sonne, et al: “Penile density and globally used chemicals in Canadian and Greenland polar bears,” Environmental Research (February 2015)
In the media
The polar bear penis article got the media hot under the collar:
- Save the Polar Bear Penises! – The Daily Beast
- Pollution is weakening polar bear penises – The Washington Post
- Is pollution destroying polar bears' penises? – Daily Mail
- Polar bear penis bone may be weakened by pollution – New Scientist
- You’ll Never Guess What Our Pollution Is Doing To Polar Bears’ Penises – MTV News
Elsevier Connect Contributor
After a few accidents, Lucy Goodchild van Hilten discovered that she’s a much better writer than a scientist. Following an MSc in the History of Science, Medicine and Technology at Imperial College London, she became Assistant Editor of Microbiology Today. A stint in the press office at Imperial saw her stories on the front pages, and she moved to Amsterdam to work at Elsevier as Senior Marketing Communications Manager for Life Sciences.