Social and Ethical Aspects of Radiation Risk Management

Social and Ethical Aspects of Radiation Risk Management

1st Edition - September 7, 2013

Write a review

  • Editors: Deborah Oughton, Sven Hansson
  • Hardcover ISBN: 9780080450155
  • eBook ISBN: 9780080914299

Purchase options

Purchase options
Available
DRM-free (PDF, Mobi, EPub)
Sales tax will be calculated at check-out

Institutional Subscription

Free Global Shipping
No minimum order

Description

Social and Ethical Aspects of Radiation Risk Management provides a comprehensive treatment of the major ethical and social issues resulting from the use of ionizing radiation. It covers topics such as nuclear fuel cycles, radioactive waste treatment, nuclear bomb testing, nuclear safety management, stakeholder engagement, cleanup after nuclear accidents, ecological risks from radiation, environmental justice, health and safety for radiation workers, radiation dose standards, the ethics of clinical radiology, and the principles of radiation protection and their ethical underpinnings. With authors ranging from philosophers to radiation protection officials and practitioners, the book spans from theoretical to practical implications of this important area of radiation risk assessment and management.

Key Features

  • Covers all the major social and ethical issues in relation to radiation protection
  • Information is easily accessible and non-technical
  • Authors include leading radiation protection officials as well as specialists who are more independent of the radiation protection system, thus presenting both authoritative and more critical views
  • Includes theoretical perspectives as well as practical experience

Readership

Health physics specialists, radiation protection authorities, industry and regulators, risk assessors and managers, students in applied ethics

Table of Contents

  • A companion series to the Journal of Environmental Radioactivity

    Preface

    Contributors

    Chapter 1. Introduction

    Abstract

    1.1 Part I. Ethical Principles for Radiation Protection

    1.2 Part II. Putting Protection to Practice

    1.3 Part III. Nuclear Accidents

    1.4 Part IV. Proliferation and the Nuclear Fuel Cycle

    1.5 Part V. Public Participation

    Chapter 2. Radiation Risks and the ICRP

    Abstract

    2.1 What is ICRP?

    2.2 The Aims and Scope of ICRP Recommendations

    2.3 The Early History and Development of ICRP Recommendations

    2.4 The Development of the System of Radiological Protection and Current ICRP Recommendations

    2.5 Ethical Underpinning of the Evolution of ICRP Recommendations

    2.6 Some Moot Points

    References

    Chapter 3. Moral Thinking and Radiation Protection

    Abstract

    3.1 Introduction

    3.2 Individual vs Collective Approaches

    3.3 Weighing vs Limit-Setting

    3.4 The de minimis Issue

    3.5 Valuing Future Effects

    3.6 Protecting the Most Sensitive People

    3.7 Conclusion

    References

    Chapter 4. A Cross-Cultural Approach to Radiation Ethics

    Abstract

    4.1 Background

    4.2 Ethics of Radiation Protection in a Globalizing World

    4.3 “Principles of Biomedical Ethics” as an Example

    4.4 Possible Sources of Cross-Cultural Ethics

    4.5 The Need for Cross-cultural Discourse

    4.6 The Relevance of the “Four Principles” for Cross-Cultural Radiation Protection Ethics

    4.7 Further Cross-Culturally Accepted Principles with Relevance for Radiation Protection

    4.8 Conclusion

    References

    Chapter 5. Ethical Aspects of Ecological Risks from Radiation

    Abstract

    5.1 Introduction

    5.2 Valuing the Environment: Philosophical Theories

    5.3 Common Ethical Principles

    5.4 Harms and Values in Practical Radiation Protection

    5.5 Assigning Monetary Value to the Environment

    5.6 Conclusion: Relevance of the Value Debate to Ecological Radiological Protection

    References

    Chapter 6. Why Chemical Risk Assessment can Learn from Radiation Risk Assessment

    Abstract

    6.1 Introduction

    6.2 Some Principles and Presumptions of Radiation Protection

    6.3 Contamination

    6.4 The Developmental Basis of Disease

    6.5 Contamination of Developing Children

    6.6 Adverse Health Effects

    6.7 Particular Substances have No Obvious Thresholds

    6.8 A Unified Approach to Dose-response Assessment

    6.9 Conclusion

    References

    Chapter 7. Ethical Issues in Clinical Radiology

    Abstract

    7.1 Introduction

    7.2 Ethics in Medical Radiology

    7.3 Medical, Social, and Legal Context for Radiology

    7.4 Risk, Uncertainty, Communication, and Skeptical Doctors

    7.5 Justification Issues

    7.6 Some Special Concerns

    7.7 Conclusions

    Acknowledgments

    References

    Chapter 8. Ethics in Practice—Protecting Workers

    Abstract

    8.1 Introduction

    8.2 Radiation Protection in Workers

    8.3 Ethical Requirements for Occupational Radiation Health Research

    8.4 Radiation Science and Workers

    8.5 Summary

    References

    Chapter 9. ALARA: What is Reasonably Achievable?

    Abstract

    9.1 Introduction

    9.2 ALARA and Optimization in the Radiation Protection System

    9.3 A Three-Levelled Model

    9.4 What is “Reasonably Achievable?”

    9.5 The Scope of Economic Compromises

    9.6 ALARA and Cost-Benefit Analysis

    9.7 Related Principles of Protection

    9.8 Conclusion

    References

    Chapter 10. Lessons Learned from the Chernobyl Accident in Norway

    Abstract

    10.1 Introduction

    10.2 Radioactive Contamination—A Societal Challenge

    10.3 Early Lessons from the Chernobyl Accident

    10.4 Long-Term Challenges and Lessons Learned

    10.5 Health Concerns

    References

    Chapter 11. Lessons from the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Disaster

    Abstract

    11.1 What Happened at Fukushima

    11.2 “Safety Culture” as a Monoculture

    11.3 Applied Ethics for Nuclear Science

    Acknowledgments

    References

    Chapter 12. Environmental Injustice Inherent in Radiation Dose Standards

    Abstract

    12.1 Introduction

    12.2 The Fukushima Accident

    12.3 Fukushima Environmental-Injustice Victims

    12.4 Poor People: EIJ Victims

    12.5 Poor People and Nuclear/Radiation Regulations

    12.6 Children: FD EIJ Victims

    12.7 Children and Nuclear-Radiation Regulations

    12.8 Nuclear Workers: FD EIJ Victims

    12.9 Workers and Nuclear-Radiation Regulations

    12.10 Future Generations, FD, and Nuclear-Radiation Regulations

    12.11 Conclusions

    References

    Chapter 13. Safety Culture and Safety Quality

    Abstract

    13.1 Introduction

    13.2 Personal and Organizational Values

    13.3 Safety Culture/Climate

    13.4 Safety Quality and Human Reliability Analysis

    13.5 Implications for Safety Management

    13.6 General Discussion

    References

    Chapter 14. The Legacies of Soviet Nuclear Testing in Kazakhstan: Fallout, Public Health and Societal Issues

    Abstract

    14.1 The Semipalatinsk Nuclear Test Site

    14.2 Research into Radiation Effects of Nuclear Testing Near Semipalatinsk during Soviet Time

    14.3 Radiation Risk Research in Kazakhstan during the Early Post-Soviet Years

    14.4 Addressing Nuclear Legacies in the New Economy of Kazakhstan

    14.5 Conclusions

    References

    Chapter 15. Moral Dilemmas of Uranium and Thorium Fuel Cycles

    Abstract

    15.1 Introduction

    15.2 Existing Nuclear Fuel Cycle: Uranium

    15.3 The Closed Fuel Cycle and Intergenerational Justice Dilemmas

    15.4 Is Thorium a Viable Substitute or Supplement for Nuclear Fuel?

    15.5 Conclusions

    Acknowledgments

    References

    Chapter 16. Social Identities and Public Uptake of Science: Chernobyl, Sellafield, and Environmental Radioactivity Sciences

    Abstract

    16.1 Introduction

    16.2 Sheep Farmers, Scientists, and Radiation Hazards: The Background

    16.3 Scientific Knowledge and Social Identities

    16.4 Public Belief and Private Dissent

    16.5 Credibility: The Social Dimension

    16.6 Conclusions: Lay Reflexivity and Social Identities

    Acknowledgments

    References

    Chapter 17. Stakeholder Engagement in Regaining Decent Living Conditions after Chernobyl

    Abstract

    17.1 Introduction

    17.2 A Key Feature of the Situation of the Population in the Contaminated Territories: The Loss of Control on Daily Living Conditions

    17.3 The ETHOS Project

    17.4 Key Lessons

    17.5 New Approach to Long-Term Rehabilitation

    17.6 Conclusion

    Acknowledgments

    ANNEX

    References

    Chapter 18. Public Participation—Potential and Pitfalls

    Abstract

    18.1 Introduction

    18.2 What is Participation?

    18.3 The Role of Participation in Democracy

    18.4 Two Ways to Justify Participation

    18.5 Quality Criteria for Participative Procedures

    18.6 Conclusion

    References

    Chapter 19. Compensation or Bribery? Ethical Issues in Relation to Radwaste Host Communities

    Abstract

    19.1 Introduction

    19.2 Host Communities

    19.3 Ethical Acceptability and Public Acceptability

    19.4 Site Selection

    19.5 Effects on the Host Community—Negative Impacts

    19.6 Positive Impacts

    19.7 Appropriate Compensation: Process

    19.8 Appropriate Compensation: Outcome

    19.9 The Inadequacy of Existing Guidelines

    19.10 Compensation, Bribery, and Incentives

    19.11 Is Bribery Unavoidable in This Context?

    19.12 Mitigation and New Build

    19.13 Bribery, Benefits, and Independence

    19.14 Financial Compensation

    19.15 Ethical Decision Making and Commensurability: Against Algorithms

    19.16 Responses

    19.17 Problems with Cost-Benefit Analysis

    19.18 Conclusions

    19.19 Afterword

    Acknowledgments

    References

    Index

Product details

  • No. of pages: 408
  • Language: English
  • Copyright: © Elsevier Science 2013
  • Published: September 7, 2013
  • Imprint: Elsevier Science
  • Hardcover ISBN: 9780080450155
  • eBook ISBN: 9780080914299

About the Editors

Deborah Oughton

Deborah Oughton is professor in nuclear and environmental chemistry, and research director of the Centre of Environmental Radioactivity, at the Norwegian University of Life Sciences (UMB). Since the early 1990s, through the support of the Norwegian Ethics Programme, she has combined a career in science with study and research on the ethical implications of radiation risk. She currently holds an associated professorship in Research Ethics at the University of Oslo, is deputy head of the National Committee on Research Ethics in Science and Technology, and ethics coordinator at UMB. She has published widely in both science and ethics, and has been a strong advocate of putting ethics into practice in radiation risk management.

Affiliations and Expertise

Center for Environmental Radioactivity (CERAD), Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Aas, Norway

Sven Hansson

Sven Hansson
Sven Ove Hansson, professor in philosophy, is a leading expert in the ethics of risk and one of the few moral philosophers who have written extensively on the ethics of radiation protection. In addition to being a moral philosopher, he is also a logician and a decision theorist. He is editor-in-chief of Theoria and editor of the book series Studia Logica Library: Outstanding Contributions. He is a member of the editorial boards of Synthese, Studia Logica, and the Journal of Philosophical Logic; member of the scientific editorial board of Philosophy & Technology; and area editor of the book series Logic, Argumentation & Reasoning. His books include The Structure of Values and Norms and Ethics at Peril. He is the author of well over 250 articles in refereed journals. He is member of the Royal Swedish Academy of Engineering Sciences (IVA) and President of the Society for Philosophy and Technology.

Affiliations and Expertise

Division of Philosophy, Royal Institute of Technology (KTH), Stockholm, Sweden

About the Series Editor

M. Baxter

Affiliations and Expertise

Isle of Seil, Argyll, UK

Ratings and Reviews

Write a review

There are currently no reviews for "Social and Ethical Aspects of Radiation Risk Management"